Switch only if that is not the job. Retrieval of a messy mixed library is a different product.
Ranked by job
1. Asking a library of links, notes, and video moments
Markwisethis site
Cheaper Pro, Copilot across saves, Focus Sessions. Loses on RSS, TTS, ebook reading, and highlight export to Obsidian.
2. Listening instead of Ghostreader-on-a-page
Matter
TTS-first. Weaker as a second brain.
3. Less product, lower price
Instapaper
If Reader felt like too much app.
Feature matrix: Markwise vs Readwise Reader